Top 10 Endangered Jobs Face Threat From Technology, Report Says

By Masako Melissa Hirsch and Alexis Espinosa
The Dallas Morning News.

Technology killed the switchboard operator, the lamp lighter and the ice cutter.

And it’s a threat for workers in a variety of other fields, from flight attendants to drill press operators to lumberjacks.

“When economies change, it kills opportunities,” said Mike Davis, an economist at Southern Methodist University. “But it also brings opportunities. If you know how to run the technology, you’re a very important person.”

The job-search website CareerCast published a report on what it says are the Top 10 endangered jobs. The report, based primarily on U.S. Department of Labor data, lists 10 jobs that could face the largest decline in workforce by 2022.

The 10 jobs, which are declining for various reasons, are letter carriers, farmers, meter readers, news reporters, travel agents, lumberjacks, flight attendants, drill press operators, printers and tax examiners/collectors.

Still, some of those workers say they’ve seen employment rise recently, with technology helping add to the workforce.

For example, online shopping makes more work for postal employees. “There actually is a little bit of a silver lining on the horizon,” said Jim Sauber, chief of staff for the National Association of Letter Carriers.

A job on the decline might still have new opportunities, said Michael Wolf, an economist with the Bureau of Labor Statistics who helped compile the original labor list. “These occupations are declining, so there might be fewer opportunities in the future, but it doesn’t mean there will be no opportunities,” he said.

Here’s a sample of workers in three of those occupations:

Baugh Farms has always been in the family.

Don and Marla Baugh have taken over some of the same land in Canton, Texas, that Don’s father farmed for 53 years. They even use some of the same old tractors. “It’s just kind of in my blood,” Don said.

Yet a lot has changed. Among the challenges, he said, it’s hard to find reliable help, and the cost of everything from the fertilizer to the equipment has gone up. They usually just break even.

“Profit margins are so thin. It takes a lot of acres to be a decent farmer, and there is only so much land available, only so much left,” said Blake Bennett, a Texas A&M AgriLife Extension Service economist.

The Baughs are at the end of their summer produce, which included heirloom tomatoes, peaches and melons, and are preparing their fall harvest.

They work every day about 10 to 12 hours. Their son, Charley, 29, helps when he’s not at his regular job at a bank.

Every Saturday, the Baughs, along with Charley, Charley’s fiancee and Don’s daughter, go to five Dallas-area farmers markets, often selling to shoppers who have become regulars. Nearly 600 people have “liked” their Facebook page. They count several restaurants as customers.

For many years, farming was a side business while Don worked for the U.S. Department of Agriculture and Marla was a teacher. They farmed to send Charley to college, Marla said. The work became full time after they both retired.

“If we didn’t have retirement, we wouldn’t make it as farmers,” Marla said.

They want to keep up their two farms so they can leave them to their children, Marla said.

And they enjoy it, she said. “You really have to love to do this, because it’s a lot of hard work.”


Margo Valencia walked through the aisles of the airplane, performing her job as a flight attendant for Southwest Airlines, just as she had since 2008.

Then she spied a man flipping through a photo album of himself with famous singers. The man, who was autistic, told her he loved to sing. Valencia smiled and handed him the plane’s intercom.

“Have you ever sung on a plane before?” she asked him.

“No,” he replied.

“Would you like to?”

The man took the intercom and a song filled the cabin.

“He had the most beautiful voice I have ever heard. I was teary-eyed,” Valencia recalled. “I asked his family later and it turned out he sang for an autistic foundation. Famous people would make appearances and that’s how he got to perform with all of them.”

Valencia thanked him for the song and pointed to a picture of him and Janet Jackson.

“She’s beautiful.”

The man responded, “Yeah, but not as beautiful as you.”

“He touched my heart,” Valencia said. “It’s moments like that that really make this job great.”

If she couldn’t be a flight attendant anymore, she doesn’t know what she would do.

“I would feel like a bird with clipped wings,” Valencia said. “This job has given me such a personal satisfaction. It has taught me how to be patient, how to be open and how to enjoy life.”

CareerCast blames the decline in flight attendants on airline mergers and fewer flights. However, Anthony DeMaio with the Association of Professional Flight Attendants, believes the industry has stabilized.

“After years of operating on the margins, airlines in the United States are turning profits, reinvesting in their product and re-establishing themselves in the international aviation industry,” DeMaio said. “Airlines are hiring flight attendants again. …

It’s an exciting time to be in the industry and working as a flight attendant in particular.”


Jonathan O’Hara, a mailman for the U.S. Postal Service, zipped down a residential street in North Dallas. At each home, he quickly sifted through his stack of envelopes and dropped several in the mailbox.

O’Hara has the routine down. He wears a rubber thimble to flip through the mail. He carries spray to fend off vicious dogs. He drinks plenty of water to beat the heat.

After 18 years as a letter carrier, he remains passionate about his job. “I enjoy connecting with my people,” he said.

The number of letter carriers has dropped across the country from a high in 1989 of 240,000 to around 190,000 in recent years, said Sauber, with the letter carriers association.

“The Internet is a double-edged sword for us,” he said.

The increasing use of the Web to communicate has contributed to the drop, though online shopping is creating a demand. The number of carriers has gone up to about 200,000 this year, Sauber said.

In less than 30 minutes, O’Hara made his way through the dozens of homes on the long block and back to his truck to pick up more mail. His daily route takes about seven hours.

The residents are like an extended family, he said.

He recalled the time he brought a gift on Christmas Eve to a child who had been eagerly waiting for days. Other times, he’s had families waiting to see if they would be evicted, and a letter he delivered changed everything.

“This route enables me to keep life in perspective,” he said. “I can see how blessed I am.”
AT A GLANCE: Endangered jobs

CareerCast, a jobs website, examined statistics from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics to compile this list of jobs that are expected to decline in number:

_Mail carrier


_Meter reader

_Newspaper reporter

_Travel agent


_Flight attendant

_Drill-press operator

_Printing worker

_Tax examiner and collector

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Popular

To Top